Bills-Dolphins Preview: Can Buffalo Avoid Another Slow Start Against Miami?
The 8-1 Buffalo Bills host the 1-8 Miami Dolphins on Sunday as roughly 17-point favorites, four days before a Thanksgiving showdown with Kansas City that could swing the race for the AFC’s No. 1 seed. Miami turns to Kyle McCord for his second NFL start, and Buffalo will wear its rivalry uniforms.
Nobody expects an upset, so the real questions are how cleanly the Bills win and who comes out healthy. Here’s what the matchup comes down to:
- Why the first drive matters more than the spread
- How Buffalo should attack the league’s worst pass defense
- James Cook’s streak and the workload question
- A pass rush that still has something to prove
- Who’s out, and who gets called up
- Predictions and hot takes
Why Do the Bills Keep Starting Slow?
Buffalo scores on roughly 58% of its drives and finds the end zone on about 37%, yet its opening possessions have been some of its least productive, and the offense has leaned on halftime adjustments three weeks running. Predictability is part of it, since the Bills run on 47.2% of neutral-situation snaps, the fourth-highest rate in the league, and early drives have too often started with a first-down handoff into a loaded box.
Joe Brady has also swung between extremes, overloading the Ravens game plan with new formations and trick plays, then going so vanilla against the Jets that Buffalo led a third-string quarterback by a point at halftime. Dave keeps coming back to one question for an offense with this much talent, which is why everything still looks so hard. His fix for Sunday is a script built on easy completions, like screens to the backs, slants to Khalil Shakir, and quick throws to DJ Moore and Dalton Kincaid.
Brady takes the ball first when he wins the toss, and Greg wants him to keep doing it against Kansas City. That only pays off if the first drive produces points, because an early lead is the best protection for a young defense. Anthony Romero, who filled in alongside Greg earlier in the week, set the bar at a three-touchdown halftime lead.
How Should the Bills Attack the NFL’s Worst Pass Defense?
Miami allows a 73.7% completion rate, last in the NFL, and Tennessee is the only other team allowing better than 70%. The Dolphins rank seventh in passing yards allowed, but that number is misleading, since opponents tend to build a lead and run out the clock on them. Buffalo ranks third in yards per attempt at 8.6, and Josh Allen is 14-3 against Miami, including the playoffs.
The run defense is middling, allowing 118 yards a game and ranking 22nd in EPA per rush. Its one real strength is stopping runs at the line, with 23% of running back carries for zero or negative yards, fourth-best in the league. That’s the formula that could keep Miami close, stuffing early-down runs, forcing third downs, and hoping for a fumble or a tipped ball.

Both shows pushed for the same opening plan, since throwing early loosens up that front. Dave pointed out that a pass-heavy first half still leaves the fourth quarter for Cook, Ray Davis, and Ty Johnson to grind out the clock. Greg wants the game decided by halftime so Allen and Cook spend the fourth quarter resting for a physical Thursday game. Against this defense, he’d be happy with 200 yards and three total touchdowns from Allen, as long as there are no turnovers.
Is James Cook the Most Underrated Back in the NFL?
Cook enters Sunday with 971 rushing yards and eight straight games with a rushing touchdown and at least 75 yards, the longest such streak since LaDainian Tomlinson in 2006. He recently passed 5,000 career rushing yards and is about 400 yards from passing Fred Jackson for third in franchise history.
Dave considers Cook a top-three back who’s at his best in the fourth quarter and gets lost nationally because Allen soaks up most of the attention. Greg agreed, saying he catches himself muttering “this guy’s good” several times a game, and that a back who rarely talks gets buried behind Allen’s headlines.
The workload is the concern, with Cook carrying 31 times against Minnesota while Davis rarely gets meaningful series even with comfortable leads. Ty Johnson handles the two-minute and pass-protection snaps, which leaves Cook carrying nearly everything else. A big lead against Miami would be the cleanest chance all season to give Davis a few drives.
Get involved with the show. Connect and tell us what you think.
Follow Dave on X: @DaveMyersBIB
Follow Greg’s new X: @ZonSports
Built in Buffalo on X: @BuiltInBuffalo_
Can the Bills Pass Rush Finally Feast on Miami?
McCord looked flustered in his first start, and the protection in front of him is among the worst in football. Miami ranks 29th in pressure rate allowed and 29th in sack rate, while its passing offense is last in completion percentage and 27th in passer rating.
Buffalo’s front hasn’t capitalized on matchups like this, with Geno Smith sitting in a clean pocket for much of the first half last week and the sacks only piling up once the Jets had to throw. Greg no longer expects the four-man rush to win consistently and wants Jim Leonhard to keep manufacturing pressure with blitzes, including the Cole Bishop safety blitz that has worked in recent weeks. T.J. Parker’s flashes against the Jets also put Bradley Chubb, facing his former team, under a brighter light.

This is also the third straight week against a backup quarterback. Sean McDermott’s defenses routinely made backups look lost, Dave noted, so a dominant day against McCord won’t tell fans much more about Leonhard’s defense. Ollie Gordon II can break a run, but Miami ranks near the bottom of the league in rushing success rate, and the bigger risk is the running back slipping out for easy catches against the blitz, which the Jets did early last week.
Buffalo Bills Injuries That Matter
Kyle Trimble, who runs the injury analytics site Banged Up Bills, broke down a long injury report heading into Friday. Christian Benford (groin) missed practice Wednesday and Thursday, and Brady rarely plays someone who sits out Friday, which points to Maxwell Hairston and Davison Igbinosun starting. Dave expects Tre’Davious White to be called up and finally get on the field.
Dee Alford remains in concussion protocol, which could mean another elevation for Te’Cory Couch. Damar Hamlin was spotted in a walking boot with a right toe injury, Dalton Kincaid is dealing with left ankle and thumb injuries, and Dorian Williams has a calf contusion from a collision with teammate Kaleb Elarms-Orr. Shaq Thompson is a possible call-up at linebacker, and Dave would also take a look at safety Justin Reid, recently released by the Saints, for depth.
Cole Bishop (shoulder) practiced fully on Thursday, and Trimble is optimistic about Amani Hooker’s knee and Ray Davis’ hamstring. A long inactive list Sunday would likely be about protecting players for Kansas City more than anything serious. Follow the latest on the Bills injury report.
Bills or Dolphins. Who’s Going to Win?
Greg gives Miami a 2-3% chance and expects a game that looks a lot like the Jets win, closer than fans would like for a while but never in real doubt. Dave would be happy with another 31-12 final.
- Greg: 24-13 Bills
- Anthony: Bills 38-13
Buffalo vs. Miami Hot Takes:
- Greg: Buffalo wins with fewer than 300 yards of offense.
- Dave: Amani Hooker gets an interception, and the Bills score a defensive touchdown
Bills-Dolphins: It’s Time to Play the Game
Thursday carries the bigger stakes, with Buffalo, Jacksonville, and Cincinnati all on pace to finish around 15-2 and the Bills facing the toughest remaining schedule of the three. A win over Kansas City on Thanksgiving would all but end the Chiefs’ hopes for the top seed. This weekend, Bills fans are rooting for the Giants over Jacksonville and Washington over Cincinnati.
Should the Bills rest players like Christian Benford and Dorian Williams on Sunday, or play everyone and pull them early?
Be sure to tune into the 1st and 5 podcast live on YouTube each weekday starting at 12 ET, and be sure to Like, subscribe, and comment.
Listen to the Bills vs. Dolphins Preview Episodes
Who has the edge?
Bills-Dolphins Side-by-Side Matchup

About The Author
Greg Zakowicz
1st and 5 co-host, and passionate Buffalo sports fan.
Pretty sure I can draft an NFL QB better than most GMs. Follow me on X @ZonSports